PHI 352Mechanism, Idealism, and Evil

Davidson College · 1 credit

Catalog

Instructor Sommers How understandable is nature? Can we truly grasp the way it works, and the reasons why it works that way, or is our impression of understanding a mere illusion? These questions were of great concern in 17th and 18th century philosophy, comprising prominent sites of debate in the scientific revolution and enlightenment. In this seminar we will explore some of the rich philosophical discourse around these questions. Three seemingly divergent lines of inquiry will turn out to converge. First, the structure of nature: Some authors in this period think that our only hope of understanding the natural world is if it is fundamentally machine-like, or mechanistic. Others disagree, arguing that instead the natural world should be understood to have a fundamentally linguistic structure, comprising a system of signs. Next, the question of idealism: Some authors in this period think that for the world to be understandable to human minds its very nature must be shaped by human minds. These authors are idealists and can be contrasted with realists, who deny the mind-dependence of the natural world. Third, and finally, the question of evil: during this period, most thinkers took the world to be created by God. To understand the world, then, is to understand what God has created for us. But why, then, does the world include pain, death, disaster, and suffering? As we will see, a number of thinkers develop versions of the idea that evil is a natural byproduct of the world being organized by general laws, the very same laws which make nature intelligible to us. The seemingly disparate topics of mechanism, idealism, and evil are in the end intimately connected to one another. Prerequisites

Recent sections

Spring 2027 · 1 section

Jan 19 – May 5

SectionDays & timeLocationInstructor
AClass #20604Tu Th · 12:15 – 1:30 PMChambers Building 3068Evan Sommers